Gaming: A Woman's Perspective


By: Lucy O'Brien
Published: Friday 8 May 2009 10:00 AM
 
Gaming: A Woman's Perspective

Women are gaming more now than ever.

What will it take to get more of us picking up the controller?

I am a girl gamer. I am an anomaly. I am a minority in an industry dominated by males. I’m a girl, I play video games, and this is freakish.

This may have been true five or six years ago, but nowadays there’s only so much we can riff on this theme. The gender lines within gaming are quickly becoming blurred, inevitable considering the youthfulness of the industry and its fast-moving technical and sociological evolution. What used to be a big deal – a ‘my god, you play games?’ response circa 90s and early 00s - now elicits a tentative ‘might see you online, then’ from the average male gamer. It’s slowly – very slowly - dawning on everyone that the Xbox plus two X chromosomes does not equal the world imploding.

While our presence may be accepted then, it is certainly not sought after, and rarely acknowledged by the industry. A study conducted by the ESA (Entertainment Software Association) in 2008 reveals that approximately four out of ten gamers are female. This is a large part of the current market; a percentage that could surely increase if there were more games marketed towards a ‘female sensibility’ - as slippery as that term might be. Nonetheless, woman gamers tend to fall through something of a target-marketing loophole, and invariably introduce ourselves to gaming, rather than gaming tipping its hat to us.

This may be a hangover from the mainly media-driven myth that gaming is for boys, and more specifically, boys who are looking for escapism through macho, violent pursuits. This myth is self-perpetuating; it seems the industry struggles between catering to us and leaving us out in the cold with nothing but a copy of ‘Imagine: Babyz DS’ while the boys sit in the living room blasting their shotguns.

For years now, mainstream video games have, on the majority, told stories about boys, for boys. There is a saturation of traditional male pursuits in videogames: battlegrounds, money soaked professional sports-fields, racing tracks and fighting arenas still par for the course. Given that women are still struggling to break these ‘glass ceilings’ in the real world, they make unlikely arenas for female characters in the virtual world. Women who have grown up on games rarely question playing as a male character, accepting it as one of the conventions of the medium. In fact, when they do crop (top) up, one often wishes they hadn’t bothered.

Traditionally, females in video games are generally camped into two areas: either as the smart, spunky sidekick/love-interest/scientist providing moral support (Alyx from Half Life 2, Sheva from Resident Evil 5, Elena from Uncharted), or as highly sexualised creatures, designed not to conquer their virtual terrain but to be leered at by their frequently male puppet masters (Lara Croft from Tomb Raider, Ivy from Soul Caliber, anyone from the Tekken or Dead Or Alive series et al.)

There are exceptions, female protagonists who are distinctively feminine but exercise strong, assertive leadership - Jade from Beyond Good & Evil and Faith from Mirrors Edge, for example - but these characters are few and far between. Fighting games such as the Street Fighter series and Tekken have always produced strong women, but they tend to lack any identifiable human characteristics (that goes for the men, too). Indeed, role-playing games are quite possibly the only genre in which females feature as heavily as males, and as such, the genre has a strong female fan-base.

There is room here to develop. It is not that we need equal amounts of representation in every title that is released, and we certainly don’t want to play as a nurse fixing up the troops in Call of Duty, or the cheerleader on the sidelines of FIFA 09. It is a simple suggestion: female characters need to be represented more faithfully, more frequently.

Perhaps the changes that need to occur, however, can’t be forced onto the current gaming landscape, but will evolve gradually as the landscape transforms. More recently, developers have begun to think outside of tradition, producing celebrated, original titles that will appeal to either sex. Sony’s creation tool LittleBigPlanet is a good example of this, as is Microsoft’s RPG Fable 2, where one can play as an equally conditioned male or female. Mirror’s Edge introduced the concept of parkour running to the action genre, and took an admirable risk in having a female lead the way.

As developers look beyond the battlefield, beyond the boy’s playground, they invite more opportunities for a strong female presence in video games. Once we begin to see ourselves as a pixilated reality, more and more of us will feel invited to pick up the controller. Perhaps one day, when the game industry realises it can communicate with females - the frightening other - it will open doors of communication to further minorities within the gaming world. An identifiable black protagonist? A gay one? Then the world really would implode.




» Return to Top

More You May Like

 

Comments (24)

You must be logged in to post comments.

or Register now!
bahamut_zero
On Friday 8 May 2009 10:53 AM Posted by bahamut_zero NZGamer.com VIP
Nice write up :) I like the trend of allowing us to choose whether we want to use female protagonists or male ones. I sometimes do tire of the same ol recycled female characters that seem to pop up throughout most games. Though the half naked ones don't bother me that much, its the 'damsel in distress' or 'cant do antyhing without a man to hold me up' characters that really peeve me off (Eg Polka from eternal sonata)
 
 
0
 
itachi
On Friday 8 May 2009 12:09 PM Posted by itachi NZGamer.com VIP
Eternal Sonata is perfect on the ps3.
 
 
0
 
ChatterboxZombie
On Friday 8 May 2009 5:32 PM Posted by ChatterboxZombie NZGamer.com VIP
this person was hitting on me on tf2 last night.
i hope to god it was a chick
 
 
0
 
simcharles
On Friday 8 May 2009 6:00 PM Posted by simcharles NZGamer.com VIP
My gf plays CoD4 on 360 alllllll the time!
She's does all nighters at least 3 times a week!!
 
 
0
 
Chronopie
On Friday 8 May 2009 6:27 PM Posted by Chronopie
Mirrors edge wasn't the first parkour game.

Perhaps the first well publicised, main stream game.
But not the first.
 
 
0
 
The Host of Chaos
On Friday 8 May 2009 8:35 PM Posted by The Host of Chaos NZGamer.com VIP
Probably the best written article I've seen on here. Good stuff.
 
 
0
 
Kiwi08
On Friday 8 May 2009 10:14 PM Posted by Kiwi08 NZGamer.com VIP
Agreed, extremely well written. Your views and passion came through very strongly.
I find female gamers attractive, and i hope that as the trend of more female gamers continues the industry adapts and accomodates such changes, resulting in better games for all! ; )
 
 
0
 
ElStefio
On Saturday 9 May 2009 12:10 AM Posted by ElStefio
I started working in a DVD/game rental store around a month ago, and I have to say that during that time I can only recall girls/women renting Singstar games. I guess that is partly because a lot of girl gamers are Wii/DS users, and we don't carry software for those systems. Maybe things are changing, but I think they still have a way to go...
 
 
0
 
simcharles
On Saturday 9 May 2009 1:17 PM Posted by simcharles NZGamer.com VIP
9 May 2009, 12:10 AM Reply to ElStefio
I started working in a DVD/game rental store around a month ago, and I have to say that during that time I can only recall girls/women renting Singstar games. I guess that is partly because a lot of girl gamers are Wii/DS users, and we don't carry software for those systems. Maybe things are changing, but I think they still have a way to go...
Why don't video stores stock Wii games??
There's a huge demand.
 
 
0
 
NotSarah
On Saturday 9 May 2009 8:57 PM Posted by NotSarah
No, see, the problem with articles like this is that you're making a big deal over the fact that you're female. As long as girl gamers are making a fuss over the fact that 'oh look, I'm female, I have more X chromosomes than you', then they will continue to stick out and be noticed as 'girl gamers'.

I'm not a 'girl gamer', I'm a gamer who happens to be female. I play games with male and female friends, and none of us make a big fuss over it. As long as you distinguish between 'girl gamers' and 'guy gamers', you're setting yourself up for people to notice that you're a girl and make a big fuss about it.

The market shouldn't need to aim itself towards female players. I'm perfectly fine with playing the games that boys do, and I don't find them too gruesome or 'un-girlish'. I find them just as fun as boys do, even if I'm not their intended target audience. People play video games because they want to play them, and if you're not happy with a video game, then just don't play it.

If you're saying that female stereotypes in video games are bad, then what about the male stereotypes? The person behind the screen most probably isn't actually a huge, buff, muscled guy wielding a machine gun, they're probably just a normal person who likes to pretend that they're the knight in shining armor, the hero who will save the day.


Wow, this is turning into far more of a rant than I'd intended it to. =/

Basically, it irks me when people complain about being girl gamers and in the minority, when (in the girl gamers I know firsthand, at least) we're actually just normal people who like to play video games and not make a huge fuss about it. As long as there are people making a fuss about girl gamers, the stereotype will continue to exist.
 
 
0
 
Gazza22
On Saturday 9 May 2009 10:17 PM Posted by Gazza22 NZGamer.com VIP
8 May 2009, 05:32 PM Reply to ChatterboxZombie
this person was hitting on me on tf2 last night.
i hope to god it was a chick
Ahhh... yeah... about that.
Sorry.
 
 
0
 
ElStefio
On Saturday 9 May 2009 10:26 PM Posted by ElStefio
9 May 2009, 01:17 PM Reply to simcharles
Why don't video stores stock Wii games??
There's a huge demand.
Honestly... I don't know.
 
 
0
 
LoNe
On Sunday 10 May 2009 8:20 AM Posted by LoNe NZGamer.com VIP
An identifiable black protagonist?
CJ from GTA:SA?
A gay one?
Quite a few RPGs (closet, but still)?

I'd place money on the industry opening more doors for entirely customizable characters a la Saints Row 2.

Good article, although tbh I would expect at least a mention of the rise of Social Gaming... buzz, GH, etc.
 
 
0
 
ChatterboxZombie
On Sunday 10 May 2009 11:35 AM Posted by ChatterboxZombie NZGamer.com VIP
9 May 2009, 10:17 PM Reply to Gazza22
Ahhh... yeah... about that.
Sorry.
*facepalm*
 
 
0
 
charlotte
On Sunday 10 May 2009 12:21 PM Posted by charlotte
9 May 2009, 08:57 PM Reply to NotSarah
No, see, the problem with articles like this is that you're making a big deal over the fact that you're female. As long as girl gamers are making a fuss over the fact that 'oh look, I'm female, I have more X chromosomes than you', then they will continue to stick out and be noticed as 'girl gamers'.

I'm not a 'girl gamer', I'm a gamer who happens to be female. I play games with male and female friends, and none of us make a big fuss over it. As long as you distinguish between 'girl gamers' and 'guy gamers', you're setting yourself up for people to notice that you're a girl and make a big fuss about it.

The market shouldn't need to aim itself towards female players. I'm perfectly fine with playing the games that boys do, and I don't find them too gruesome or 'un-girlish'. I find them just as fun as boys do, even if I'm not their intended target audience. People play video games because they want to play them, and if you're not happy with a video game, then just don't play it.

If you're saying that female stereotypes in video games are bad, then what about the male stereotypes? The person behind the screen most probably isn't actually a huge, buff, muscled guy wielding a machine gun, they're probably just a normal person who likes to pretend that they're the knight in shining armor, the hero who will save the day.


Wow, this is turning into far more of a rant than I'd intended it to. =/

Basically, it irks me when people complain about being girl gamers and in the minority, when (in the girl gamers I know firsthand, at least) we're actually just normal people who like to play video games and not make a huge fuss about it. As long as there are people making a fuss about girl gamers, the stereotype will continue to exist.
I don't think that the writer was complaining about being a girl gamer - she was pointing out that the current gaming culture has a tendency to alienate SOME women. Just because some gamers 'just happen to be female' doesn't mean there aren't a steaming bucket of women who could just 'happen to be gamers' if the industry didn't largely insist on pushing its games with images of large breasted women and well endowed men. Absolutely games are a fantasy world, and who doesn't want to play as a heaving mass of masculine muscle occasionally, but as a women who just happens to feel like its not such a crime to differentiate yourself on the basis of gender , and who also games, I would love to have more options when it comes to playing as a character that reflects this particular aspect of my personality (i.e. my vag). For me, the underlying tone of this article was not one of criticism, but rather of encouragement, from someone who clearly loves games and just wants to see them keep moving onwards and upwards. Thus, high-five Lucy O'Brien. High Five.
 
 
0
 
bahamut_zero
On Sunday 10 May 2009 6:08 PM Posted by bahamut_zero NZGamer.com VIP
Exactly. The article is more about the stereotyping of female characters within the games than the female gamers themselves.
 
 
0
 
lexcalibur
On Monday 11 May 2009 10:18 AM Posted by lexcalibur NZGamer.com VIP
Really nice article, well written.

Haha, sounds horrible to say but I think the excessively large breast thing is the biggest problem with female protagonists. Obviously Lara Croft is the perfect example, because they are large she is seen as something for guys to drool over, if they were smaller however she would be seen as the strong female lead that she is.

The only difference between her and Faith from ME is chest size, why would this make Lara any less of a role model for young girls? I don't know about other people but I don't assume a girl is an idiot because she has a larger chest...
 
 
0
 
Chris Redfield
On Monday 11 May 2009 9:40 PM Posted by Chris Redfield NZGamer.com VIP
Video gaming hasn't had it's Ripley to show how a strong female protagonist should be done.

Good article.
 
 
0
 
Cindysm
On Tuesday 12 May 2009 11:41 AM Posted by Cindysm
Here, here. Well said. I have been playing since the huge PS1 box came out. But right now I find that the games for the PS3 are seriously lacking. Im holding on tightly to my old faithful PS2 games for the sake that there is very little to replace them with.
And beating up women and killing for the sake of killing has never appealed to me. Give me a "save the universe" and Im happy. And I always choose the female character.
 
 
0
 
Xyttik
On Wednesday 13 May 2009 8:13 PM Posted by Xyttik NZGamer.com VIP
Awesome article Luce.

I just wish more girls would actually stop going on about how they're "ZOMG I'M A GIRL GAMER!!" and just get on with their gaming
 
 
0
 
Omg_a_kid_with_GTA
On Thursday 14 May 2009 9:45 PM Posted by Omg_a_kid_with_GTA NZGamer.com VIP
9 May 2009, 08:57 PM Reply to NotSarah
No, see, the problem with articles like this is that you're making a big deal over the fact that you're female. As long as girl gamers are making a fuss over the fact that 'oh look, I'm female, I have more X chromosomes than you', then they will continue to stick out and be noticed as 'girl gamers'.

I'm not a 'girl gamer', I'm a gamer who happens to be female. I play games with male and female friends, and none of us make a big fuss over it. As long as you distinguish between 'girl gamers' and 'guy gamers', you're setting yourself up for people to notice that you're a girl and make a big fuss about it.

The market shouldn't need to aim itself towards female players. I'm perfectly fine with playing the games that boys do, and I don't find them too gruesome or 'un-girlish'. I find them just as fun as boys do, even if I'm not their intended target audience. People play video games because they want to play them, and if you're not happy with a video game, then just don't play it.

If you're saying that female stereotypes in video games are bad, then what about the male stereotypes? The person behind the screen most probably isn't actually a huge, buff, muscled guy wielding a machine gun, they're probably just a normal person who likes to pretend that they're the knight in shining armor, the hero who will save the day.


Wow, this is turning into far more of a rant than I'd intended it to. =/

Basically, it irks me when people complain about being girl gamers and in the minority, when (in the girl gamers I know firsthand, at least) we're actually just normal people who like to play video games and not make a huge fuss about it. As long as there are people making a fuss about girl gamers, the stereotype will continue to exist.
*Clap* *Clap* *Clap*

You have a great point =]
 
 
0
 
Xenojay
On Friday 15 May 2009 9:53 AM Posted by Xenojay NZGamer.com VIP
10 May 2009, 06:08 PM Reply to bahamut_zero
Exactly. The article is more about the stereotyping of female characters within the games than the female gamers themselves.
As the blog states and reiterated by bahamut_zero, I agree there aren't any strong female leading characters, though Jade from BEYOND GOOD & EVIL is the best example of a well designed heroine. But could we also maybe consider CHELL from PORTAL?? Yes, she was just escaping from the facility, but she was quiet, determined, and awesome with that gun. And even though LEFT 4 DEAD is based around group play, ZOEY seems headstrong in that zombiefied world amongst the males.
I think like FABLE 2 and LITLLE BIG PLANET, FALLOUT 3 must be considered also as that has a great balancing system for both genders, right down to the LADY KILLER and BLACK WIDOW perks.
I also think in terms of the DAMSEL IN DISTRESS characters, why is PRINCESS PEACH missing?? She's one of the very first of that "HELP ME" group. Plus, there's that awesome demotivational poster of her proving the CAKE is a LIE from SUPER MARIO 64.
 
 
0
 
simcharles
On Friday 15 May 2009 8:25 PM Posted by simcharles NZGamer.com VIP
9 May 2009, 10:26 PM Reply to ElStefio
Honestly... I don't know.
One day they will!
Maybe in the next generation!? LOL
 
 
0
 
Your_Final_Fantasy
On Wednesday 17 Jun 2009 10:13 PM Posted by Your_Final_Fantasy
Wow you are awesome. If i even try talking about games with guys at school i get a weird looks, although after i can show that i actually know what i'm talking about they start being a little nicer. It's almost like you cant be a girl and like video games. Ok so there may be some of us that like sing-star and the "Girl Games" but i find Final Fantasy to be way better than sing-star or bratz.

I fink the female characters need to be a little more assertive and not just a side kick or love interest. And "some" (speaking bout the minority here) guys need to realize that girls can be just as good as guys when it comes to games.
 
 
0